cans with coins and air horns), a spray bottle, a chin “cuff” (a smack), a muzzle hold, and pinning the dog to the floor. Positive reinforcement, negative reinforcement, positive punishment and negative punishment all provide avenues to changing behavior, and while interconnected, each is quite different from the others. But a punishing consequence may also occur when something nice is taken away from the dog, as when the other dog stole his supper. For some dogs, like mine, the diminished appeal wouldn’t take very long and then that’s pretty much it for that thing. However, he has issues with resource guarding, particularly when it comes to rawhide bones that are soft enough and small enough to swallow. Dog trainers debate the role of reward and punishment in shaping a canine’s behavior. The dog trainers here talk about dominance theories and tell us to jab the dog and hold him down to get him to do what we want. As someone who has trained both ways, having been for many years a traditional trainer, I can vouch for the improvement in the way I relate to my dogs when the use of punishment is ruled out of the equation. Punishment includes scolding, leash corrections, alpha rolls, or anything else that scares or hurts a dog. Alternatively You could pay for a dog walker or sitter. Five questions for a veterinary behaviorist about training and punishment. If the lead goes tight, we stand still. Also I have seen video from Dr Yin, where she uses a brief period of negative reinforcement, via a head collar, to initially obtain some eye contact with a reactive dog in the presence of another dog – it was literally 5 seconds and the head collar pressure ceased immediately eye contact was established. Again – “positive” refers to adding something. For example, asking the dog to “sit”, then adding a cookie to the picture, makes sitting a behavior that is likely to be repeated. The dog obeys learned cues in order to avoid the punishment. The puppy, who was living in a hole in the sidewalk, is now 3 1/2 months old. learning is the flip side. I don’t think we can talk about learning theory or it’s use as being intended for any specific purpose. Advances in animal science and understanding canine behavior and cognition led to these effective and humane training techniques. Dogs used to be trained mostly with punishment-based training, but positive reinforcement is becoming more popular. Using positive punishment for example simply means that you do something to, or around, your dog that he would rather avoid. In practice it is more effective and better for your dog to be trained with positive reinforcement. Let me know if your boy grew out it or if you finally found something that worked and I’ll do the same. A nicely written article, very clearly explained. You may have been told that food is cheating, or just for little puppies and that your dog should work for a pat and a kind word. modifying behaviour through positive reinforcement, positive reinforcement training is the future, https://thehappypuppysite.com/how-to-stop-your-dog-stealing/, https://thehappypuppysite.com/the-evidence-for-positive-reinforcement-training-in-dogs/, https://thehappypuppysite.com/top-dog-training-youtube-channels/, https://thehappypuppysite.com/reinforcement-in-dog-training/, Best Harness For A Cockapoo – Walking Your Dog In Comfort. It’s the system of using them all, appropriately, that makes behavior modification successful. Common Dog Training Myths: There is more than one way to train a dog. One of the problems with using positive punishment is that it can be very difficult to get that timing right unless the dog is right next to you, and he won’t want to be next to you if you punish him. I probably didn’t make that very clear. Behaviourists call these positive and negative punishments respectively. I appreciate the tip on searching for “balanced training” and your objective thoughts. Using punishment won’t necessarily speed up your training, but trying to cut corners and train more quickly is likely to lead to more punishment. However, most experts agree a role does exist for positive and negative reinforcement in the training process. What the puppy wants to do, is move forwards, and we are removing that option when we stand firm. But new puppy owners are often in a hurry to cut down on rewards. It is true that many forms of punishment are very mild and do not physically harm the dog and in theory, there is nothing intrinsically terrible about punishing a dog provided that the punishment is appropriate and not harmful.